Nurses make legal and ethical determinations when caring for patients ; determinations that need to be made carefully because the determinations could perchance alter a patients’ life. There are theories to explicate how to job work out ethically and the theories are non based on emotion ( Guido. 2006 ) . This paper will discourse the relationship between legal and ethical issues and ethical theories. illustrations will be provided.

Ethical motives can be described as rules and criterions that are a usher to carry on used to promote the criterion of conformity ( Judson & A ; Harrison. 2010 ) . Ethical motives is derived from the Grecian word “ethos” moralss explains actions as right or incorrect in regard to cultural rules and values. Moral values are personal beliefs that are intertwined with ethical actions and behaviours ( Guido. 2006 ) . Ethical motives. similar to values. are individualistic and they come from our experiences. civilization and actions. While one’s values or moral moralss may be different. the nurse’s ability to conform to a patient’s ethical behaviour is of import ( The VA leads alteration toward Integrated Ethics attack. 2008 ) .

The legal system was created to set up policies to protect the populace ( Judson & A ; Harrison. 2010 ) . The Torahs that are set can be changed when grounds suggests amendments are necessary. The relationship between jurisprudence and moralss is evident when discoursing a patient’s health care determination that goes against the norms or beliefs of the health care supplier. An illustration would be the patient exerting his or her right to decline intervention for a disease procedure that will ensue in at hand decease. such as a patient in nephritic failure declining dialysis ( Guido. 2008 ) . Shannon ( 2008 ) discussed the differences of legal and ethical determinations as “morally ordinary” and “extraordinary” intervention related to the proviso of aided nutrition and hydration. peculiarly for patients in a “permanent vegetive state” ( p. 894 ) .

Metaethics is a nonnormative moral principle that attempts to depict the deduction between moral constructs or statements and the justification of why something is regarded good or ethically right. Normative moralss understand criterions of behaviour and application of these behaviours in life. Normative ethicsbranch out into two wide classs called deontological and teleogical theories ( Guido. 2006 ) .

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now

Deontological theories focus on the intended action non the effects of one’s actions ( Guido. 2006 ) . The theory focuses on the self-respect and sense of responsibility of the persons and finds the relationship between the individual and the action. Deontological theories are divided into two subcategories ; move deontology and regulation deontology. Guido ( 2006 ) states that “act deontology is based on the personal moral values of the individual doing the ethical determination. whereas regulation deontology is based on the belief that certain criterions for ethical determinations transcend the individual’s moral values” ( p. 4 ) .

Teleological theories are based on the simple construct. right actions have good effects and bad actions have bad effects. This theory suggests the act of right or incorrect is straight related to the effect of the action. Utilitarianism stems off of teleogical theories. explains that effects count and Acts of the Apostless are determined by the effect. Some utilitarian’s believe that the moral rightness of a effect is determined by the greatest figure of good or the least injury and agony ( Guido. 2006 ) . Sing the moral rightness is based on greatest figure to profit from the greatest good. actions based on the utilitarianism theory can frequently be unethical and illegal.

Nurses in ague attention scenes are faced day-to-day with ethical issues and concerns. Shannon ( 2008 ) examines the footings “morally ordinary” and “extraordinary” in regard to patients in a “permanent vegetive state” ( p. 894 ) . It is thought if we can maintain the organic structure alive we should. “capacity generated obligation” but there is a via media in human self-respect. doing this both a legal and ethical quandary ( Shannon. 2008. p. 894 ) .

Euthanasia and terminal of life attention frequently cause a batch of animus. as they have been distorted by general populace. Shannon ( 2008 ) provinces. “Discontinuing medical processs that are onerous. unsafe. extraordinary. or disproportionate to the expect result can be legitimate ; it is the refusal of over-zealous treatment” ( p. 898 ) . This statement defines euthanasia in its most recognized signifier backdown of intervention. This makes the act legal. but is it ethical to retreat intervention that was started to prolong life. cognizing that the consequence ends in decease? Another illustration of an ethical issue in an ague attention puting is continuing variety meats for contribution in a patient who is pronounced dead following a cardiac event. Organ contribution is a personal pick that can be expressed though written consent by the giver. Although. if there is no certification of the patients wants. household members have to do the determination in the event of unexpected decease.

Is it legal and ethical to keep the organic structure of a patient who has died in order to maintain the variety meats feasible while waiting for the family’s determination ( Bonnie. Wright. & A ; Dineen. 2008 ) ? When a patient has been declared dead harmonizing to neurological standard infirmaries will keep organ viability while expecting household determination about contribution. Procedures are started postmortem by a graft squad to find campaigning for contribution. Medicines are started and extra lines are inserted. All of which are done after the patient is declared dead. This is legal in many provinces. in fact there is a legislative act called the “immunity clause” to protect the wellness attention workers from any liability. but is it ethical ( Bonnie. Wright. & A ; Dineen. 2008 ) ?

Harmonizing to Bonnie. Wright. and Dineen ( 2008 ) . “Organ saving in instances of uncontrolled cardiac decease violates no lawfully protected involvement of the household members. It does non represent “mutilation of the body” and falls comfortably within the general rule that infirmaries have no responsibility to present cadavers to households in their exact status of death” ( p. 744 ) . See this statement and topographic point an ethical accent on your thought procedure. Healthcare workers are non lawfully bound to present the organic structures of their loved 1s in the exact status of their decease.

In decision. through cultural norms. behaviours. beliefs. and attitudes the ethical behaviours of healthcare workers are analyzed. The regulating organic structures of health care such as the American Nurses Association and the American Medical Association mandate health care workers to continue ethical values in his or her pattern. The legal system maintains the right to look into and analyze determinations made by health care practicians when determinations appear unethical or possibly improper. The assorted ethical theories provide way for health care practicians and moralss review boards with decision-making procedures.


Bonnie. R. . Wright. S. & A ; Dineen. K. ( 2008 ) . Legal authorization to continue variety meats in instances of uncontrolled cardiac decease: continuing household pick. Retrieved April 29. 2009. from EbscoHost Database.

Guido. G. W. ( 2006 ) . Legal and ethical issues in nursing ( 4 ed. ) . Upper Saddle River. New jersey: Pearson Prentice Hall.

Judson. K. & A ; Harrison. C. ( 2010 ) . Law and moralss for medical callings ( 5th erectile dysfunction ) . New York. New york: McGraw-Hill.

Shannon. T. ( 2008 ) . Unbind him and allow him travel: Ethical issues in the finding of proportionate and disproportional intervention. Theological Studies. 69. 894-917. Retrieved April 29. 2009. from MasterFILE Premier database.

The VA leads alteration toward Integrated Ethics attack. ( Cover narrative ) . ( 2008. December ) . Medical Ethical motives Advisor. Retrieved May 1. 2009. from Academic Search Complete database.


I'm Niki!

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out