The story Turned is a story focused on betrayal and the way the wife Mrs Marroner is betrayed and her husband is disloyal when she finds out he has been sleeping with there Swedish servant, Gerta. The story then turns when Mrs Marroner and Gerta leave. The story in a sense is also about deceitful and about unfaithfulness. The context of the story shows life would be difficult for Gerta alone in the world. Her Turn is another story that has strong themes that runs through it there is a lot of selfishness and manipulation.
It was set in 1912 where mining strikes were at there worst and there are a family of 4 who are living with their husband, Mr Radford who is a miner on strike. Mrs Radford is very greedy and the writer shows she gets a “satisfaction” from her. This is all focused on her manipulation and her selfishness wins over her husband. In The Story of an Hour it was set in 1894 and the story is a bit about death and this is one of the main themes . The story is starts when she hears her husband has died and her she starts to feel all kind of emotions.
These emotions get the better of her and she gets carried away and eventually dies. Another theme is about her freedom from depression in her marriage. The 3 stories are about women having a relationship with men and something has gone wrong and that is one of the writer’s techniques. Another is that all the women seem to be in some sort of competition with there husbands. The Story of an Hour is about two people, Mr Mallard and Mrs Mallard. Mrs Mallard is trapped in a “storm of grief” in a marriage that is like a prison. Mrs Mallard is heart- broken when she hears the death of her husband.
She hears from a telegram that her husband was in a train crash and “she wept at once. ” She couldn’t believe he was dead “a paralysed inability to accept” this is showing the moment where time stopped and she is unsure of what to feel and she is unable to believe he’s dead so when she will see him again she will “weep again”. There is a sense of new live and we get the image of a “new spring life,” when she stands at the window. The author mentions the wildlife like “twittering of the sparrows” Mrs Mallard see something coming to her. We get her side of the story and her sense of freedom.
Mrs Mallard says “”free, free, free” and this is when she realises she is free from her husband. At the end of the story she dies of the shock of seeing her husband again. The emotions come flooding back and she is unable to cope. The author shows us that women found it hard in that time and sometimes there emotions were so strong they died from not being able to cope with there new found freedom. This shows that she has kind of won a competition for her freedom and is celebrating her victory all though these celebrations lead to her death. “Of jot that kills” this shows her emotion overwhelmed her and her joy is what killed her.
She first feels sad but then she gets to understand the situation and realises her freedom from a man who put her in a “storm of grief”. The position of women in the early 1900’s was harsh because in Turned and The Story of an Hour it’s about women galloping away from life of torture. The Story of an Hour shows us the feelings that Mrs Mallard got when she was free show that they were powerful and unpredictable and in Turned this shows us you can easily deal with your problems and the writer shows us this at the end when she moves on and lives a new life In Turned, Mrs Marroner is represented as a rich well brought up person.
She is a woman of many talents. She has a PHD and had been to college, which is unusual for women of that time. Women in that time were expected to stay at home and be housewives. She is left with always knowing of her husband’s betrayal. Mrs Marroner is betrayed when she receives a letter form her husband who is on a business trip. Although the letter wasn’t meant for her it was for their Swedish servant Gerta. The letter mentions that he will be home to take care of Gerta soon and enclosed with the letter was fifty dollars. Mrs Marroner did not know what to feel.
Eventually they leave to start a new life together as a new alliance Gerta, Mrs Marroner and the baby. There is a contrast from this story and The Story of an Hour its that both women are breaking free from their husbands but Mrs Mallards emotions implode on her and get the better of her. Mrs Mallard repeats the same words “Free! Body and soul free! ” this shows she overwhelms herself with emotions and they implode on her. Mrs Marroner “can channel her emotions” and manages to cope with being “independent” looking after herself and Gerta and her baby. She is a strong woman who looks out for herself and Gerta.
Also in this story the writer uses water imagery. This symbolises the hatred and misery that runs through the story and the swirl of emotion. The writer uses this at specific points of the story. Where the story is about to turn. The story has a strange structure to it as the main story starts half way through and then it takes us to a crisis point and the water imagery shows us where the story leads us next. “Begged her with streaming tears” and “like a flood rising around a house” are quotes used by the writer who uses this to show anger, hatred and suffering from crying.
This story is in contrast to The Story of an Hour because Mrs Marroner is with her husband who she never sees but if she left him she would have the money and the brains to get off her feet again Her Turn is very different to Turned because in a sense they’re about betrayal. In Turned her husband who was sleeping with another women, Gerta, betrays Mrs Marroner Her Turn shows this by Mr Radford is betraying his wife when money was stretched and she goes on a spending spree and also a bit about breaking away from depression. Her Turn this is about a woman called Mrs Radford and her husband.
Mrs Radford is represented as a greedy and scheming character that is described as having a cat like appearance with a “sleek face” and the writer uses this to show her character as a “very sleek”, secretive person who saves money when it is stretched and spends it. The writer presents a completely different side of women in the 1900’s. This is shown by women having a dominant effect on men’s lives. The story shows Mr Radford as a tortoise. This shows him as a slow and easy controllable person no matter how hard he tries. People will always be able to control Mr Radford.
This is shown at the end of the story. “She gave him a shilling” and he accepted it, and this shows “the large man” who had “considerable strength” and who “had plenty of friends” is left taking money off his own wife who is “jealous” of what her husband has and is. This story is very different to Turned because the way women are presented in this story is that they have strong emotions which control them and they flee from their problems and this story shows that the male dominates and this women are left to pick up the pieces of betrayal, hatred and anger.
Her Turn shows the context of when the mining workers were on strike and are unable to get enough money to survive that well. Mrs Radford who exploits this and collects together a lot of money and goes on a spending spree when the family needs it to live. She uses her sense of anger, selfishness, greed and satisfaction to do it and makes her husband beg for money. This story is different to all the rest because in this story she is trying to get away and have freedom she is manipulating her husband. In the other stories they’re trying to get away from the husbands.
The context of these stories all reflects the main themes and story lines of the stories. In Turned Mrs Marroner is a “strong” and “very clever” woman who understands the social background of Gerta. She realises the dangers of a Swedish, 18 years old, pregnant woman all alone would be. Through her determination she “forced herself to understand and extenuate the girl’s misdeed and” … “her ruined future”. They manage to flee from the man who did the crime the “ignorant” man “which he” … “took advantage of” Gerta.
Through there persistence they get away. They “achieved” their freedom and they got “bursts of feelings” which they never had before under the authority of Mr Marroner. These stories all reflect the social and historical background of the position of women in the late 1800’s to early 1900’s. These stories show 3 women trying to cope in marriages that have huge emotions and take up almost half of there lives. The emotions in the stories are powerful and it shows that in The Story of an Hour where the powerful emotions lead to the death of Mrs Mallard.