Machiavelli Vs Socrates Essay, Research Paper
Puting: This argument between Socrates and Machiavelli takes topographic point on a cheery afternoon on Baltimore s Inner Harbor. Both arguers are offering advice to this twelvemonth s presidential campaigners, Al Gore and George W. Bush. The argument is happening out-of-doorss and is moderated by Jimmy Fallon of Saturday Night Live. Three registered electors, with strong positions on topics pertinent to themselves, are primed with inquiries they want answered. The argument is about to acquire underway as Jimmy is get downing to travel over the land regulations for each arguer.
Jimmy: Each of you dead cats has two proceedingss to give your reply. Members of the audience who have already been selected have certain inquiries for you on run subjects. Each individual saying a inquiry will hold his or her mike turned off after he or she speaks. Keep in head that you are simply saying your instance or point of position, you are NOT reasoning with your opposition. Without any farther bustle, allow s get down. The first inquiry asked is from David Stauffer and it is directed towards you Socrates. Mr. Stauffer, will you delight province your inquiry?
Dave S. Good afternoon to you, Jimmy. I watch you every Saturday and I ve got to state you re screaming. Anyway Socrates, I have a inquiry on the topic of instruction. I myself am an pedagogue in the private school system of this cheerless province. I am inquiring what your stance is on the verifier system?
Socrates: That is a good inquiry. I believe wholeheartedly in the verifier system. Every kid should be entitled to a first rate instruction. Our primary end ; nevertheless, should be to reform public schools across this state. Their criterions are low and school systems across this state are rip offing childs out of a first rate instruction. It is clip that we as a state semen to raise the criterions of our public schools. I praise Governor Bush extremely for his stance on doing schools, and hence instruction, more equal for all involved. However, one must maintain in head that formal cognition doesn t needfully do one wise.
Jimmy: Umm, good said Soc. On to you Machiavelli. Show your side of this statement?
Mach: Yes. Well, Mr. Stauffer, unlike my opposition, I am steadfastly against the verifier system. If parents can non afford a good instruction for their kids so that is their job. I feel as though public schools in this state are equal plenty. There can non be excessively many educated people, they are a menace to stableness. Too many members of the clerisy, I believe, will turn out fatal for the state. Bush s program of equalising schools sickens me. I believe he should avoid making that at any cost.
Jimmy: Yeah, certain whatever you say. Up following is Terri Archibald with a inquiry about abortion. The inquiry is addressed to you, Machiavelli. Mrs. Terri Archilbald, will you delight province your inquiry?
Mrs. Archilbald, a middle-aged, fleshy Caucasian adult female stairss to the head.
Arch: Mr. Machiavelli, I d like to cognize your stance on the ever-touchy issue of abortion. Do you believe it should be outlawed?
Mach: Well, Terri, while I do non believe you ll of all time be faced with the issue personally, I do non believe it should be outlawed. In fact, I am a st
rong protagonist of abortion. In looking at the facts, the process really has benefits. Abortion helps to maintain an already high population in cheque. This leads to cut down competition in the work force and in the pool of pupils using to college. A reasonably sized population is critical to keeping the order of the province. I besides feel as though twosomes with two kids, with others on the manner, should earnestly see abortion as an option. I appreciate the fact that Al Gore is pro-choice, but he should toughen his place.
Jimmy: Okay Soc, will you delight give your place?
Soc: Will you please name me by my name, Jimmy? My sentiment on this affair differs with that of Machiavelli. I am pro-life all the manner. Life is a sacred gift of God and should be cherished and respected. Personally, I tend to believe of abortion as expectoration in the face of God. Human life is cherished and should be preserved at all costs. Abortion should be outlawed, as it is nil but slaying. In respects to this topic I must clap Gov. Bush for his pro-life stance. Al Gore, who supports Roe v. Wade, should see changing his stance.
Jimmy: Thank you Socrates. Our concluding inquiry comes from John Rocker, who some of you may cognize as the controversial closer for the Atlanta Braves. This inquiry is addressed to you, Machiavelli. Mr. Rocker, you re no No-mar, but go in front and inquire your inquiry.
Rocker: That s right Jimmy ; I m better than that cat. I even scored over 1200 on my S.A.T. s. Anyway, this has to make with the size of the military. Machiavelli, what are your ideas on the current size of the armed forces of this state? I ask because I might be traded shortly, and if so, I ll need a occupation.
Mach: Now, here s a good inquiry. I feel as though the armed forces of this state demand to be built up. As the universes merely staying world power, I believe we need to be ready to maintain less powerful states in line and demo our musculus. A strong ground forces is important to keeping our state s security from menaces both at place or abroad. A swayer of any state must be on guard to protect his state from any type of menace. The easiest manner to make this is through readiness and force. Since the campaigner s have really similar stances on this issue, my lone advice to them is to travel in front and beef up the armed forces.
Rock: See, that s what I m speaking about. There s a existent adult male with some testicular fortitude.
Jimmy: Will person please turn that imbecile s mic off? Okay Socrates, you re up.
Soc: The size of our military should be reduced, or maintained at its current size. We merely need the smallest figure of soldiers necessary to keep peace. Peace should be our primary nonsubjective. We can non advance peace through constructing up weaponries and demoing our musculus to the remainder of the universe. I think both campaigners should cut down the size of both the armed forces and violent weaponries.
Jimmy: Well what do you cognize? We re all out of clip. Thank you both Socrates and Machiavelli for coming out today. I m certain the electors of the state appreciate it. To all of you viewing audiences at place, delight melody in every Saturday at 11:30 p.m. to NBC s Saturday Night Live. This hebdomad s invitee is Scott Moore. It ll be a good show, watch it!