No signifier of authorities can survive… when the life of the state is at interest. ” Because I agree with Clinton Rossiter. I affirm the declaration that When the United States is engaged in military struggle. the demands of national security ought to supplant conflicting claims of single rights. Definitions from Encarta World English Dictionary Engaged in Military Conflict means contending unfastened warfare. Demands of national security means protection against loss. onslaught. or injury to the citizens. Ought to supplant agencies that there is a responsibility or duty to take the topographic point or place of something. Conflicting means non able to be followed or acted on. because each requires different and incompatible actions. Claims of single rights are demands for entitlements. freedoms. or privileges a individual has. Before I begin. I have an observation about the declaration. The demands of national security and claims to single rights must be viewed as legitimate. Because the declaration says ought. we are debating about whether or non national security is a justifiable cause to restrict rights.
I am continuing SOCIAL WELFARE as my value. Societal public assistance is the conditions under which person may populate satisfactorily in a community. The standard continuing my value is the PRESERVATION OF SOCIAL ORDER. The United States has the duty to its citizens to continue the society by moving on the demands of national security. Contention I: Government is created to continue public assistance by curtailing single rights. Before authorities was created. we live in what John Locke called the province of nature. In this province of nature. worlds were perfectly free. However. we are non able to bask these rights because we are non provided safety. We enter a authorities in order to continue life. autonomy. and belongings. Locke provinces: “ [ Man ] gives up [ self-power ] to be regulated by Torahs made by the society. so far forth as the saving of himself. and the remainder of that society shall necessitate ; which Torahs of the society in many things confine the autonomy he had by the jurisprudence of nature. ” Even when adult male is in harmoniousness with authorities. certain single rights are limited.
When in military struggle. nevertheless. justness and security are both compromised. and something must be done to protect them. Contention II: Government must supply for the safety of the society during war by farther curtailing rights. The highest duty a authorities has is to supply the protection of its citizens. and certain rights that may be allowed in less vulnerable times may endanger national security during military struggle. Because new forces endanger the society. new steps must be taken to continue social order. Jean Jacques Rousseau affirms this. “Only the greatest dangers can outweigh that of altering the public order. and the sacred power of the Torahs should ne’er be interfered with except when the safety of the state is at interest. ” Even certain constitutional rights may be temporarily superceded during these times. Political Science Professor Martin Shaffer explains: “To run into the challenge of a major exigency. the barriers against almighty authorities established by the fundamental law must frequently be transcended. ”
Contention III: Government has the responsibility to protect its citizens. When the authorities restricts rights. it does so to supply security to its citizens. Assuming. as we should under this declaration. that national security is at hazard. authorities. by come ining this societal contract with its people. has the overall duty to protect social public assistance. It must curtail certain freedoms of look. privateness. and due procedure if it will protect the people. Security must come before rights. Abraham Maslow’s hierarchy of demands topographic points security merely above physical demands such as nutrient. H2O. and shelter. Without security foremost. rights become invalid and authorities is unable to work. Work forces can non esteem a authorities that does non continue society. In decision. as a legitimate authorities. the United States has the duty to protect social public assistance. Because it must protect its citizens above all. impermanent violations on rights are necessary.