William Butler Yeats’s poems “Easter 1916” and “The Second Coming” each portray the subject of rebellion. However. rebellion is non ever heroic and these two verse forms clash with one another to turn out this point. “Easter 1916” contains text which presents rebellion as a positive action ; whereas. “The Second Coming” makes the reader believe rebellion merely leads to pure pandemonium and upset until the terminal of clip. In add-on. Claude McKay’s verse form “If We Must Die” supports the thought of rebellion as a positive. honest motion with illustrations throughout the text. Narratives of defiance and gallantry have been used throughout history to animate and give hope of something greater. Throughout “Easter 1916” . Yeats speaks of Ireland’s development to an independent. stable. changed state. For Ireland to accomplish such stableness. they need rebellion. Rebellion and alteration go hand-in-hand in this verse form because there can non be alteration without some type of rebellion. Throughout this verse form Yeats speaks of alteration in the people which finally leads to the Easter Rebellion. they desire a alteration for a better life. He says. “That woman’s yearss were spent/In nescient good-will. /Her darks in argument/Until her voice grew shrill” ( SITE QUOTE ) which implies that this adult female dedicates her yearss and darks to contending for Ireland’s Huff 2
rights as a state. Yeats speaks of these sufferers to animate the people of Ireland and to demo the people that they can do a difference. Change is so of import to the Irish people because they continuously watch as settlements become metropoliss and metropoliss become united states. The Irish eventually decide to go the state they desire to be. and they accomplish this through a rebellious phase which is really of import. Furthermore. Yeats continuously says. “A awful beauty is born” ( CITE HERE ) throughout “Easter 1619” . This quotation mark is highly important because it describes the integrity of Ireland’s citizens to accomplish independency ; nevertheless. lives will be lost in the procedure. The “terrible” of the quotation mark is all of the blood and decease Ireland faces due to the rebellion.
However. this rebellion is so honest and heroic because Ireland is under England’s control. The Irish program the rebellion cognizing they are put on the lining their lives for freedom. The “beauty” of the quotation mark lies within the integrity of the people for the first clip for the greater good of the people every bit good as the possibility of freedom from England’s control. On the contrary. “The Second Coming” paints a different image of rebellion. Yeats writes. “Things fall apart ; the Centre can non keep ; /Mere lawlessness is loosed upon the universe. ” ( SITE HERE ) which describes the universe at the clip of a rebellious period. The universe is literally falling to pieces because it is the terminal of clip. Rebellion in this verse form is non epic ; alternatively. rebellion seems to mean the terminal of life as people know it. Of class all rebellion involves upset. pandemonium. and normally decease. but rebellion does non function as much intent in this verse form as it does in “Easter 1916. ” Rebellion marks the terminal alternatively of a new beginning in “The Second Coming” .
In “The Second Coming” . the society widens and widens out of control. Yeats includes his emotions into this verse form when he speaks of the Christian Revelation of the 2nd approach of Christ. Yeats. along with the people of this society. is looking for a alteration. They believe that the coming of Christ may be the alteration they desire at this clip. This verse form is full of expectancy because the people want a manner out of the lives they are populating. and can non stand the incubus they are in. Just as Yeats did in “Easter 1916” . McKay’s poem “If We Must Die” besides tells a narrative of how being rebellious can besides in many ways be heroic. He writes “O kinsmen! we must run into the common enemy! Though far outnumbered allow us demo us weather. and for their 1000 blows cover one coup de grace. ” ( Cite here ) saying that though they are far outnumbered and decease is a great possibility they will stand together and fight until the really terminal.
Together they will arise as a group in hopes of a better life. contending the impossible conflict but looking every bit heroes to the 1s they are contending for. There have been many other narratives where heroes have formed from characters being rebellious. Robin Hood is a good illustration of defiance. In the narrative “Robin Hood” the chief character Robin Hood leads a set of predators and confronts corruptness in their local small town taking to the rebellion of the male monarch. He takes the gold that he steals and gives it to the hapless townsfolk in the small towns controlled by the male monarch. This is the perfect instance of how being rebellious can be heroic. Though Robin Hood is a vigilance man and a stealer he appears to be a hero to the people of the many small towns. Every narrative of defiance can be looked at positively as gallantry or negatively as a instance of lese majesty. Huff 4