Report On Winnipeg City Council Essay, Research Paper

City Politicss

On October 9, I attended the City of Winnipeg, Executive Policy Committee run intoing which was made up of Mayor Susan Thompson, Councillors Bill Clement, Jae Eddie, Mike O & # 8217 ; Shaughnessy, Amero Silva, and Garth Steek. On the docket for that twenty-four hours was a presentation by the Yellowhead Highway Association, a hearing deputation from Councillor Lillian Thomas ( Elmwood ) , sing the redesignation of land between Gateway Road and The City of Winnipeg Hydro Transmission Line, South of Springfield Road and a treatment sing the sale of land adjacent to Omand & # 8217 ; s Creek between St. Matthews Avenue and the Winnipeg Velodrome.

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now

The presentation from the Yellowhead Highway Association ( YHA ) by Linda Walker, was a basic update sing the advancement of developments that have been happening along the main road, how the YHA is working with City of Winnipeg touristry to advance the metropolis every bit good as a history of the YHA.

The Executive Policy Committee, seemed to be reasonably uninterested with the work that the YHA was making as many members seemed to be making other things such as reading the paper and speaking to associates. Susan Thompson commended the association & # 8217 ; s work in assisting with the publicity of the City of Winnipeg along with the development of the Yellowhead Highway. The lone remark that came from another member of the commission was from Councillor Mike O & # 8217 ; Shaughnessy who felt that a map that was included in the YHA & # 8217 ; s information bundle should be updated.

I thought that the presentation done by The Yellowhead Highway Association was really enlightening as to how the group helps advance touristry and what betterments are being made to the Yellowhead Highway. This was the first clip that I had of all time heard of the YHA and after the presentation, thought that their group was a benefit for the citizens that travel along the Yellowhead Highway. I was surprised to see the council members show so small attending or entheusim to the YEA since they are the people, who we as citizens of the City of Winnipeg, elected to stand for us.

The 2nd issue on the docket was sing a hearing on the redesignation of land from a vicinity policy country to an industrial policy country which would industrial park criterions to the land. The land involved is & # 8220 ; about 55 estates & # 8221 ; ( docket, 101 ) between Gateway Road and The City of Winnipeg Hydro Transmission Line, South of Springfield Road which is owned by the Palliser Furniture Company. Originally the land was designated as industrial but was changed to a vicinity policy in 1989. Palliser has decided to reassign & # 8220 ; 50 % of its fabrication capableness from their North Carolina works to their Winnipeg works & # 8221 ; ( docket, 101 ) and have reapplied to hold that package of land designated as industrial in order to spread out the works.

This subject was presented by Councillor Thomas who wanted the hearing sing the redesignation to be held in the eventide at the East Kildonan & # 8211 ; Transcona civic offices due to the fact that most of the citizens populating in that country work throughout the twenty-four hours and a good response from the countries citizens would be improbable. Councillor Thomas did non give her sentiment of the proposed amendment as she wanted to wait until after the hearings to see how her components felt on the issue. The other Executive Policy Committee members had no remark on the issue and it was decided that a finalisation on the times and day of the months of the hearing sing the rezoning of the land would happen in the close hereafter.

Since I do non populate in the country, it is easy for me to state that the metropolis should travel in front and rezone the land in order to let the Palliser Furniture Company spread out its installation. I can understand that the occupants might hold some concerns sing the land as to what will go on to the belongings value, will resound degrees be increased, and will their revenue enhancements be adjusted, but as it stands today, that country is covered in weeds and is more of an eyesore than it would be if Palliser did spread out their works on that land. With Palliser at that place, at least you would be assured that the batch would be clean like the bing Palliser works in the Vulcan/Burnett industrial country. Plus the extra occupations that would be created would be a encouragement for the metropolis and its economic system which is something that can non be ignored.

The 3rd subject of treatment was most likely the chief event of the Executive Policy Committee meeting. Many members of the local media were on manus to see what would go on to the proposed sale of land located at the & # 8220 ; southeast corner of Empress Street and St. Matthews Avenue & # 8221 ; ( study, 2a ) which was officially an exceeding association football bowl called Alexander Park, that easy deteriorated and was finally lacerate down in favour of the Winnipeg Soccer Complex to house major association football events.

The American-based company, Home Depot wanted to purchase the & # 8220 ; 13.9 acre batch & # 8221 ; ( Martin, A10 ) in order to develop it into a & # 8220 ; 105,000 square pes hardware shop & # 8221 ; ( Martin, A10 ) at the monetary value of & # 8220 ; 5.1 million & # 8221 ; ( Martin, A10 ) . Due to the complexness of this issue and the figure of people who wanted to talk about the development of the land, the commission decided to suspend the regulations and let all deputations to talk in the metropolis council hall in forepart of all the council members and the city manager. Deputations on manus were the Friend & # 8217 ; s of Omand & # 8217 ; s Creek, MLA MaryAnn Mihychuk ( NDP-St. James ) , Home Depot landscape designer Michael Scatliff, and legion people from the West End.

The major lodging point in shuting the vitamin D

eal was the fact that the occupants were concerned with the new belongings line as the bets were already in the riverside which did non let adequate room for a paseo to be built along the brook and proper buffering to be planted.

The positions taken by metropolis council seemed to be in favour of the proposed sale of land to Home Depot. Councillor Glen Murray ( Ft. Rouge ) supported the undertaking said he felt that Home Depot was traveling in the right way with merely a few inside informations to be ironed out. Councillor Al Golden ( St. Vital ) besides supported the undertaking but did non travel right out and state it, alternatively he asked minor inquiries to Home Depot & # 8217 ; s landscape designer Michael Scatliff that made it clear that he supported the undertaking. The lone council member to travel out and publicly province that she was against the undertaking was Councillor Thomas. She asked Michael Scatliff legion inquiries sing edifice programs, the proposed paseo along Omand & # 8217 ; s Creek, and of the possible buffering that was traveling to be planted but, all of the inquiries she asked could hold been answered by herself if she would hold taken the clip to read the Report From the Board of Commissioners. The one council member who I was surprised that did non province his sentiment publicly was Councillor Amero Silva ( Daniel McIntyre ) . It was his ward whose citizens were being affected the most and his refusal to notice on the issue showed a deficiency of representation on behalf of his wards people.

The biggest job I felt that lead to the eventual failure of the bar of the development of the Alexander Park land was the fact that there were excessively many groups present with excessively many issues and suggestions without holding one common end. MaryAnn Mihychuk was concerned with the seasonal garden centre as it was excessively close to the brook and should be moved to the south side of the edifice. The Friends of Omand & # 8217 ; s Creek were concerned with the edifice and wanted it moved at least three metres west of the brook & # 8217 ; s riverside. Other occupants of the West End were at that place to state that they did non desire the edifice at that place at all, and alternatively wanted it for the green infinite. With all these thoughts, it is easy to see how the occupants best involvements were non listened to.

I was disappointed to see the metropolis go in front and allow the sale of land to Home Depot for a few grounds. As a local association football participant, I can retrieve when Alexander Park was the best association football field in the metropolis, and place to the elect squads of the metropolis. The past few old ages at that place had been a rumour circulating in the association football community that Alexander Park Stadium would be rebuilt and place once more to some great association football lucifers, but that was rapidly abolished in my head when I heard of the proposed sale of the land to Home Depot. More significantly though, I was concerned about the negative impact it would hold on the economic system. Yes, the undertaking would make immediate employment supplying many people with occupations, but with the great buying power that Home Depot has, their monetary values would be reduced by so much that the little, local hardware shops would be forced out of concern and we can merely think as to how many concerns this will be. A perfect illustration of this is a state of affairs the occurred in Winnipeg this past spring. Hallas Hardware located in the North End on MacGregor Street near Mountain Avenue had been functioning local clients for about 50 old ages selling the traditional hardware shop points to featuring goods. Hallas Hardware was a fixture in the North End with its big bleached letters on the forepart that gave the edifice its character, was forced out concern with the debut of monolithic shops like Canadian Tire, Superstore, and Wal-Mart and their monolithic purchases and utmost undercutting. I can merely think as to who will be following to be forced out of concern with the debut of Home Depot to the Winnipeg market. Is all this worth it for a metropolis the size of Winnipeg which already has adequate elephantine price reduction shops?

I felt this was a good experience to see metropolis council in action and to detect merely how they go about in doing alterations and developments to our metropolis. Before the meeting I thought that what would be taking topographic point at the meeting would be uninteresting and deadening but I was really incorrect. It turned out to be rather interesting when observed live compared to the recorded version on telecasting. Besides it was rather interesting to watch how the council members reacted to the media & # 8217 ; s presence. At the Executive Policy Committee Meeting in the West Committee Room where no media was present, all the council members acted reasonably normal and down to Earth. Equally shortly as the meeting shifted to the council Chamberss where all the council members were present along with the media, the attitudes and reactions were wholly different. Councillor Golden kept on running around between his place and someplace behind the scenes. When he did talk, he was loud and disconnected. Councillor Bill Clement ( Charleswood ) looked as if he was resting in private with his custodies behind his caput while Councillor Thomas made certain everyone knew when she was talking and how she felt. I sort of made me inquire in the terminal why we elected these people and are they truly looking after the citizens in their wards as most of them seemed to be in it merely for themselves.


City of Winnipeg. Agenda of the Executive Policy Committee for October 9, 1996.

Winnipeg, 1996.

City of Winnipeg. Report From the Board of Commissioners from October 7,1996.

Winnipeg, 1996.

Martin, Nick. & # 8220 ; Home Depot Deal OK & # 8217 ; d. & # 8221 ; Winnipeg Free Press 10 October 1996, sec. A:10.


I'm Niki!

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out